I saw this last night. My thoughts:
I was pretty much expecting to hate this film. I've never really seen the Sixth Sense properly (just in lots of bits) and knew the twist long before i even saw any of it. Unbreakable - to me - was pretty rubbish and Signs was just very average for the most part.
But weirdly, i came out feeling like i'd enjoyed The Village. This isn't to say I think it's a consistently good film - because it's clearly not - but there are brief moments of quality film-making which show Shyamalan to have talent which I never thought he had.
Bits like the scene when that guy's on the watch tower and you see the red-cloaked figure walk under it. I can't remember the last time I saw a collective cinema audience jump in unison to such a degree. Then there's the bit in the forest where the horrible thing starts running at the girl and the camera. People around me were actually screaming. Like, really Screaming. Because those bits are genuinely unsettling - they're brief, straight-forward and they're not very frequent, but when when they do happen they're top notch. I always remember the bit in Signs with the children's party and the alien moving across in the distance. Can't really recall much else from that film, but it's that kind of moment within which Shyamalan excells.
Which leads onto my main problem with the film. Shyamalan's great at the short-term scares, the jump out of seat moments, but when it comes to long-term atmosphere and building tension it all seems a bit flat. It often feels like it's all fragmented and chopped up just so all the important information surrounding the twist will work. The middle of the film suffers for this and it all gets a bit meandering.
But ultimately I think the payoff is worth it. Shyamalan seems to work on a huge scale and then zooms in as he's writing/filming. His dialogue is therefore incredibly stilted in places, but the end twist kind of justifies this. I was sitting in the cinema during the first hour or so amazed that I could be watching a film so bad, but by the end I was questioning my own judgements due to the revelations revealed to me. I think moments like that are of genuine value - when you suddenly realise a film has completely tricked you in every way. You're sitting there watching with a set of values, a set of benchmarks upon which you make your judgement, when you suddenly realise these were just preconceptions, stupid little metres by which we desperately try to judge and make sense of things. The twist in The Village isn't just a twist in plot, it's a twist in genre, setting and our quality judgements of the film.
I can see why people would feel cheated by this. I guess it feels a little cheap and a little easy. But I was left satisfied by it and this genuinely surprised me.
Also: Bryce Dallas Howard's performance is rather grand throughout - one to watch methinks.