Jump to content

The Mandalorian - Season 2 (open spoilers for big surprises)


Recommended Posts

2 hours ago, Stoppy2000 said:

A lifetime fan of Star Wars should find more to enjoy in the Mandalorian than you seem to... If i disliked it as much then I'd just stop watching. I presume you have seen the whole lot now? 

 

I went to see Empire in the cinema when it came out. Tried to move pencils across my school desk with the Force. Appeared in an issue of PC Format with a hexidecimal hack to bring dead pilots back to life in the original X-Wing. I'm fan enough. Doesn't mean I enjoy mediocre Star Wars for Star Wars' sake. And I think I'm being misrepresented - I don't want sparkling Wheedon-esque dialogue, I just want a soul to it. I'll finish it off tonight, I've got a couple of episodes to go. Just a shame it couldn't be better. I'd trade some of the visual splendour for just a whiff of character. That's all I'm saying, I don't find it offensively bad or anything.

 

And my desert island scifi/fantasy shows? Babylon 5, ST:TNG, Orville, BSG, Buffy, Firefly, Misfits, Futurama, Red Dwarf, Fringe, X-Files... I dunno really.

 

Actually, look at Witcher, who's the most important character in that? 

Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, cavalcade said:

 

I went to see Empire in the cinema when it came out. Tried to move pencils across my school desk with the Force. Appeared in an issue of PC Format with a hexidecimal hack to bring dead pilots back to life in the original X-Wing. I'm fan enough. Doesn't mean I enjoy mediocre Star Wars for Star Wars' sake. And I think I'm being misrepresented - I don't want sparkling Wheedon-esque dialogue, I just want a soul to it. I'll finish it off tonight, I've got a couple of episodes to go. Just a shame it couldn't be better. I'd trade some of the visual splendour for just a whiff of character. That's all I'm saying, I don't find it offensively bad or anything.

 

And my desert island scifi/fantasy shows? Babylon 5, ST:TNG, Orville, BSG, Buffy, Firefly, Misfits, Futurama, Red Dwarf, Fringe, X-Files... I dunno really.

 

Actually, look at Witcher, who's the most important character in that? 

Watch it to the end and tell me it has no 'soul'. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Don't know if anyone else is keeping up with the rumours but it's being reported that Robert Downy Jr is being cast as Thrawn, hope it's not true, I was really hoping for Lars Mikkelsen as he voice dhim perfectly in Rebels and hell the guy looks just like him.

Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Mogster said:

 

I don't think The Mandalorian or the Expanse are only good because of "pew pew layzors" (indeed, The Expanse is a layzor free zone), but also I think this is a bit reductive when it comes to shows like this. I think The Mandalorian has a lot more soul than you give it credit for, but it also has some incredible action scenes that would never work on stage but make for great TV. I do think it has some excellent character moments mind.

 

I strongly disagree that it's only seen as good by so many due to references to older Star Wars stuff too. My wife loves it for a start, who can't stand Star Wars outside of this show and had next to no knowledge about the universe. I know she's not exactly alone there either. I think there's really only one scene that leans on existing material to give it some of its weight (and it's brilliant), but it does so while also being a key point for the characters and plot of the show itself. Modern Star Wars is often criticised of being a "remember THIS?" experience that leans too heavily on nostalgia, but I think there's a balance to be struck between throwing in old stuff for the hell of it, and using it tastefully to build a cohesive universe. I think The Mandalorian manages the latter far more often than not.

 

Pew pew layzors in the action scene sense. In the Expanse.... brrpbrrrp machine guns. I'm not saying it's poor because of the Star Wars references - though saying it only has one scene that leans on nostalgia is crazy talk - but it's a hollowed out experience that depends on a cloud of third party analysis to flesh out the vestigial storytelling and characterisation. I have no doubt people watch it and enjoy it, but people watch any old shit and it has a cuddly Yoda and talking frogs in it doing a lot of the heavy lifting. 

 

It's fine, I have no great amount of skin in the game. I just wish that like Witcher they realised that having a gruff monosyllabic central character required some support in the wider cast. And I'm no great fan of the Witcher either, which has all sorts of other problems, but it seems like such a basic thing to sort out. But whatever, we have discussed to death. Some people love it, I think it's fine but a little soulless and dull. I'm sure Disney give not two fucks about what I think.   

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, cavalcade said:

Pew pew layzors in the action scene sense. In the Expanse.... brrpbrrrp machine guns. I'm not saying it's poor because of the Star Wars references - though saying it only has one scene that leans on nostalgia is crazy talk - but it's a hollowed out experience that depends on a cloud of third party analysis to flesh out the vestigial storytelling and characterisation. I have no doubt people watch it and enjoy it, but people watch any old shit and it has a cuddly Yoda and talking frogs in it doing a lot of the heavy lifting. 

 

What about it requires third party analysis?

 

When I talk about leaning on nostalgia, I mean in the sense that scenes involving existing characters work entirely on their own merits and the setup in the show. This is partly because Mando as a character has no prior knowledge about them, so their only significance to him is the same as that of a Star Wars newcomer. The one exception absolutely leans much harder on nostalgia to build it up, but it does it really well and it still totally works on its own merits with everything else going on in the scene.

 

And yes, some people watch any old shit, but I wouldn't class myself as someone like that. I'd watch almost anything Star Wars related, I'll give you that, but I certainly wouldn't enjoy it just "because Star Wars". For you it might be a hollow experience, but for my wife and I it was genuinely emotional.

Link to post
Share on other sites
17 minutes ago, Mogster said:

 

What about it requires third party analysis?

 

When I talk about leaning on nostalgia, I mean in the sense that scenes involving existing characters work entirely on their own merits and the setup in the show. This is partly because Mando as a character has no prior knowledge about them, so their only significance to him is the same as that of a Star Wars newcomer. The one exception absolutely leans much harder on nostalgia to build it up, but it does it really well and it still totally works on its own merits with everything else going on in the scene.

 

And yes, some people watch any old shit, but I wouldn't class myself as someone like that. I'd watch almost anything Star Wars related, I'll give you that, but I certainly wouldn't enjoy it just "because Star Wars". For you it might be a hollow experience, but for my wife and I it was genuinely emotional.

100% agree with this. If this was bad then I wouldn't watch it just for the Star Wars bits. It's literally some of the best Star Wars output. 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Matt Defis said:

Don't know if anyone else is keeping up with the rumours but it's being reported that Robert Downy Jr is being cast as Thrawn, hope it's not true, I was really hoping for Lars Mikkelsen as he voice dhim perfectly in Rebels and hell the guy looks just like him.

 

Downey would be a terrible pick for Thrawn, not just because everyone will just think "It's Blue Iron Man!" but because he's utterly unsuitable for the role, he's never done any work to show he would be a good match for what's needed. I hope that's just people running with the "Favreau and him are pals and SW is going to be Marvel now" bit and nothing based on fact...

I would also say that I hope they DONT cast Mikkelsen as Thrawn in live action. Yes, perfect in Rebels as the voice. In live action? No. I don't want Thrawn introduced as some decrepit Limmy lookalike.

Link to post
Share on other sites
37 minutes ago, Glasgowchivas said:

 

I would also say that I hope they DONT cast Mikkelsen as Thrawn in live action. Yes, perfect in Rebels as the voice. In live action? No. I don't want Thrawn introduced as some decrepit Limmy lookalike.

 

Nope, they should actually cast his brother Lars instead. He's the better actor anyway, but relatively unknown outside Scandinavia unfortunately.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Ahh sorry! Whoops. Oh well, I think he'd be good personally and I agree that visually he'd be a close approximation to how I've always pictured Thrawn, with the acting chops to back it up. And let's face it, how we all picture Thrawn is how he was depicted in Tie Fighter surely? :wub:

 

Anyhoo, after seeing the entire season, I thought it was mediocre with only episode 5 being actually very good indeed.

Spoiler

The less said about Luke's appearance the better. Just a meaningless, emotionless duel with robots, shot poorly and with a ridiculous sub mid noughties CG face, imo. Goodness me.

Oh well, it passed the time and there were some nice moments sprinkled around. Nice to see so many seemed to enjoy it too and got back into Star Wars. I really hope they inject some quality into the 3rd season though. And by that I mean stop it with the celebrity directors and writers and just let Filoni do the whole thing. Obviously none of that will happen.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm not familiar with Filoni's other work but his episode was head and shoulders above the rest here, which is a bit embarrassing considering that the majority of the others were established live-action directors.

 

Taika's one last season was weak as well, I seem to recall some people raving about it but the lava boat stand-off was absurd. To be fair he didn't write it, but the scenario just didn't work visually.

Link to post
Share on other sites

What I find interesting is that from a casual roam around the net, it's clear that a large segment of the fans who hated the sequels, love this. Especially after this seasons finale. Yet I feel this suffers from the exact same things which made me dislike the recent sequels, terrible writing and lazy, poor directing.

 

In this instance I feel Cobra Kai is giving the Star Wars 'creatives' an utter schooling. I'm 5 episodes in to season 3 and it's just an utter joy. Every single frame, every line of dialogue drips with passion and understanding. Imo, you just know that the people behind the show have a complete love of the source material, era and the characters and they have the passion and intelligence to pull it off.

Link to post
Share on other sites

So I've just finished watching it tonight with my wife. We pretty much did a marathon session through season 2. Overall I really liked it and certainly beats anything else output set in the Star Wars universe in a long while.

 

Although I'm sure this has probably been discussed to death, there is one thing about the series which bugged me. That is how invulnerable all of the main characters are. I think the final episode would have had a lot more weight to it if they battled to the bridge, several of them taking hits and regroup only to be faced with the onslaught of the bots. They close the blast doors and give each other a look like "well, I guess this is it" :( look.

 

As it is, each episode showed them literally walking towards enemies firing and hitting every time. It destroys any tension as they deflect and literally dodge lasers! Stormtroopers also seemed to forget how to fire their weapons at times and just walk towards our heroes whilst being mown down. It just breaks the immersion for me, but still good and thoroughly enjoyable overall. I'd give it an 8 out of 10.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I've watched Season 1 now (yes I am behind as I only got Disney+ recently due to them offering me 2 free months) and hmmmmmm it is ok, decent Star Wars but not what I was expecting given the rave reviews! Has tv scifi become so tawdry that the Mandalorian warrants being welcomed as a 2nd coming? (all of that references the reviews etc - I haven't read much of this thread as - spoilers - obviously)

 

So eight episodes and a mixed bag - I could write a full writeup review on each but Im guessing they have been discussed to death so I will keep it short (for me!)

 

Episodes 1-3 - A basic introduction to the series and it's main overarching plot.

 

Episode 1 - Intro to stuff - not bad. The carbonite was a bit wtf considering how it was used in Empire - now a couple of years later Mando has them lined up like popsicle sticks in his storage bay. The character of Mando is interesting but the performance is not really great - it lacks ummmm weight is wrong word but will have to do. Carl Weathers was really good though.

3/5

 

Episode 2 - Our first show of how the rest of the series will pan out, a story of the week with elements of the over arching plot as well. A good compromise between the old style of TV series where we get a new story and a reset button every week and the new style where we get a story told over 10-15-20 episodes.  The story of the week is a good one, if a bit simple (a common theme in the Mandolorian) and Nick Nolte is superb, almost unrecognisable.

4/5

 

Episode 3- A weaker episode that leans too heavily on action and is mostly about the overarching plot. the Mandolorian's motives are obvious but the performance doesn't back it up.  A bit meh as an episode but it does setup the rest of the series quite well.

2/5

 

Episode 4 - defend the village - In the 80s the showrunner of the A-Team would have read this and popped it in as mid-season filler... By the numbers... mediocre... sigh... but it has an AT-ST woo!

2/5

 

Episode 5 - MEMBER-BERRIES! The universe in Star Wars seems to revolve around Tatooine - yawn. The story  of the week is ok I guess but it's simple and by the numbers again with no real meat to it - I don't care enough about the guest people as I don't know them and my main cast I am meant to care about is a muppet and a guy in a helmet who doesn't say much.... it doesn't quite gel for me yet.

2/5

 

Episode 6 - Prison break! As close to a bottle show as a multi-million dollar production like this gets :DIt mostly takes place in one corridor set and focuses on the guest of the week characters who are mostly great with Clancy Brown as a standout for me as the "heavy".  The purple headed lady was overacting her arse off for the whole thing which was most distracting and the droid in the ship getting distracted by baby yoda just seemed pointless as it added nothing to the story. Overall though a good episode , old fashioned fun action.

4/5

 

Episode 7 - The overarching plot returns and is superbly realised. Great buildup and good character moments. Getting the gang back together was a bit trite but worked and the climax was very well judged and heartbreaking... That moment made the episode the 5/5 it was superbly paced just right to make you think one thing then pull the rug. This is a great setup episode to what should be a fantastic finale!

5/5

 

Episode 8 - Ohhhhhh dear - A laughable climax which is utterly bonkers and makes zero sense. The standoff outside the bar is utterly daft "you have until SUNDOWN" errrrr why not just do it now, you already shot out half a wall! A gatling gun blaster can't open a metal panel? "We can't shoot our way out" followed by THAT scene which just put them back where they started? And then on the boat faced with far less they HAVE to let the droid do THAT? I mean it looks like the scriptwriter gave his son some crayons to write his own conclusion and accidentally submitted that one instead of his own! It has a couple of standout moments like Mando using the XXXX taking down the YYYY with the thing very impressive. But the way they dusted their hands and said yep that's that without checking anything? and then THAT reveal... rubbish booo

2/5 (and it should think itself lucky to get that - I added 1 in sympathy to episode 7 which set things up perfectly).

 

Overall - 3/5

 

In the main it is a decent show but, for me, it struggles as the main character is just not charismatic enough. I know why it is I know his motives and I can see his performance can be good but often when I think of the episodes alllll of the things that stand out to me are the things that are not the main character. I love the other characters far more and when it is a "story of the week" episode that has no good characters or disposable ones I tend to lose interest. Also the way it does memberberries stuff "subtly" is just as annoying to me and episdoe 5 would have been just as good without all that bollocks stapled into it - maybe better as they would have spent the time on other things!

 

The other main positive is the production design and production value - it is obviously high budget and shows but it has been constructed perfectly and shows how Star Wars should be done in terms of look and feel.

 

The bad bits are of course all fixable and I'll be tackling season 2 next so it is good enough to warrant following it :)

 

 

Oh and I really don't get the whole love-in for Baby Yoda... but that's fine each to their own :D

Link to post
Share on other sites

I think season 2 is stronger, but it'll be interesting to see what you think of it based on that writeup. I loved the season 1 finalé and thought the prison break episode was one of the weaker ones. :D

 

Also it's worth looking into how it's shot if you haven't already. It's obviously not a low budget show, but they do some fancy stuff to make it seem more expensive than it really is. There's also a lot of movie props getting re-used, and for the last two episodes they even

 

Spoiler

flew in a bunch of actual Stromtrooper cosplayers along with their home made armour.

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

The prison break was fucking shit, made all the worse by the awful pantomime overacted twileks and every scene looking exactly the same as the last. I don't fully get the bottle episode thing when a hell of a lot of the scenes were done in UnrealEngine in a virtual stage. Must have cost 10 pence.

Link to post
Share on other sites
9 minutes ago, Nicky said:

The prison break was fucking shit, made all the worse by the awful pantomime overacted twileks and every scene looking exactly the same as the last. I don't fully get the bottle episode thing when a hell of a lot of the scenes were done in UnrealEngine in a virtual stage. Must have cost 10 pence.

 

The unreal engine stuff was on a screen. The sets the characters interacted with were mostly real with the odd bit of green screen.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Finally! I should’ve known I could rely on RLLMUK for at least some grumpy criticism. Mostly agree with Clipper on S1.

 

This may be one of the most overrated shows of all time. It LOOKS fantastic. I love a lot of the casting...

... but the writing is laughably bad. No people speak like people do in some of the episodes of this. Many episodes are monster of the week except bad.

 

Some episodes are great (the prison break one) but they are rare.

 

The fan service and small-universe-ism is absolutely excruciating.

 

The last episode had me rolling my eyes so hard. Imagine watching that if you had no idea who *that* was? It would make absolutely no sense at all because there is no set up.

 

Film Crit Hulk wrote an essay on each episode and he nails down very well what made me feel so uneasy about the weak ones: https://www.patreon.com/filmcrithulk

 

Interesting mega essay on the Assassins Creed games too (which I agree with a bit less...).

Link to post
Share on other sites
58 minutes ago, Nicky said:

The prison break was fucking shit, made all the worse by the awful pantomime overacted twileks and every scene looking exactly the same as the last. I don't fully get the bottle episode thing when a hell of a lot of the scenes were done in UnrealEngine in a virtual stage. Must have cost 10 pence.

 

Similarly I just do not get the finale at all.

 

Spoiler

The wall was blown out last time - so we have Moff Gideon (yeah that's his name no sniggering he is an ultra hard badass honestly!) getting a billion storm troopers to assemble a big gun to blow the bar to bits. He pontificates for ages with a half decent speech then says "you have til sundown" - he is dealing with 3 people in a bar and half the wall is gone! What purpose is there to waiting? - I know you might say ooooooh he wants Baby Yoda alive but at the beginning of the series we were told it was fine to bring him in dead or alive and IG-11 was just going for the simple route of dead hence getting extra ventilation in his head from Mando.

 

So that is daft... THEN IG-11 finds the baby yoda and shoots the speeder bike guys (I did love the speeder bike guy chat at the beginning) and he decides to not run off and get in the ship but go into the town and rescue Mando and team? Why?

 

In the bar super hard rebel lady using the gatling gun blaster to open a sewer grate which, it turns out, its made of Vibranium for some reason?

 

Then IG-11 returns and it is obviously a killing machine. This means that the 3 in the bar who were SO CERTAIN that shooting their way out was bad suddenly think its great to go outside and try to shoot their way out - IG11 is pretty good with blasters so ok.

 

Somehow the shootout ends with them back in the bar? Who wrote that? I mean that is what you write when you are past your lunchbreak and you think "oh I'll quickly scribble this then fix it later" except they forgot to go back and fix it :D

 

THEN we are back in the bar and the IG11 can easily sort out out the sewer grate made of unobtanium.

 

Then into the sewer to find mystical armour Mandolorian and well its ok but the storm troopers take exactly as long as it takes for the plot to move to find our heroes :D

 

Finally they use a boat with (MEMBERBERRIES) an R2 unit which hahahaha get this yeah... ready... yeah... has ARMS AND LEGS woohoo top joke. My word.... :facepalm:

 

Then oh no the lava stream outlet has an ambush waiting for it there might be about 12 stormtroopers waiting for them! I mean forget the fact that IG11 took on way more than that and the team despatched a fuckton of them outside the bar - these 12 are deadly serious. So serious IG11 has to sacrifice himself with a T2 moment...... ooook

 

Finally Mando does something very cool to take down Moff Gideon's (no really it is a serious name!) Tie Fighter. It doesn't explode but mmmmmmeh he is probably dead so the team do backslapping and walk off into sunset.

 

And then? ohhhhhhh Gideon isn't dead after all... SHOCK.

 


And THAT is why the finale , to me, is not great :D

 

 

 

I like the prison break because - despite the overacting by purple lady (and purple guy actually) and the stupid droid hunts baby yoda it was a fun little episode. Contained, compact with loads of nice touches... Clancy Brown was really good as well.

 

Compared to the Tatooine MEMBERBERRIES episode and the village ATeam episode it was great!

 

 

 

 

FInally regarding finale the reason I am so down on it is that the setup in 7 is actually good it honestly felt like Best of Both Worlds where part 1 is brilliant and they then forgot they had to do part 2 and then got the crayons out :D

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Well this thread suddenly got depressing. I want the unbridled positivity back!:P

 

Regarding spin-off characters being "jarring" though, at the time the show aired there was no indication that any spin-offs were in the works. I thought they were used really well, and didn't get the impression that they were just there to promote other shows.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Well I'm rewatching S1 with my daughter and I'm enjoying it just as much as the first time.

 

I much preferred S2 but looking at the show as a whole, I think it's absolutely tremendous.

 

There you go, @Mogster, some more positivity for you.

Link to post
Share on other sites

 

 

Yeah as others have said, season 2 is definitely better than season 1.

 

46 minutes ago, MardiganX said:

 

When I watch this show I do so with the enthusiasm, joy and smile of a child.

 

When I watch this the pacing and the plot elements do seem to me to hark back to an 80s TV show and I watch it in that context.  Yes some of the plot elements are a bit daft, but so what? Suspend your disbelief.  Clipper mentions the A Team and yes, there's a similarity in places. 

 

I absolutely loved Star Wars as a child.  My father taking me to see the first film is one of of my earliest memories. I had a lot of the toys and Empire and Jedi were huge events.

 

The prequels left me cold.  They aren't very good and are a huge wasted opportunity. Absolutely terrible. I saw them at the cinema and laughed at large parts of them.

 

The sequels are okay, and while better than the prequels, don't hang together fr me at all.  I don't really see the point of any of them.   Underwhelmed but I don't hate them like the prequels.  And I got to tale my oldest son to the cinema to watch them.

 

I really enjoyed Rogue One.  The best of the post Jedi films in my opinion.  But the tone is very different from Star Wars.  Its darker.  And I find that a little odd.

 

Solo is fine.  I enjoyed it more than the Sequels (or Prequels obviously).  Yes they crammed a lot of Solo's backstory into one film.  But I liked it.

 

Mandolorian is to my mind, the best Star Wars since Jedi.  The tone, 80s TV show, works for me because that is how I approach it, like Mardigan X, as an enthusiastic child, and on that basis the Mandalorian is great fun.  And for me it's the best Star Wars since Jedi.

 

So don't take it too seriously or look at it too critically - enjoy it for what it is, a space romp much like Star Wars.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I can see why people don't like the Saturday afternoon feel so it, but I really enjoy the story of the week element- even if it was if you want x first you have to help with y every week.

Link to post
Share on other sites

yep I am onboard with story of the week , I grew up with it so it does fit for me but sometimes it can be a bit too formulaic as I pointed out :D So some good some not so good.

 

I watched first episode of season 2 and I need to spoiler

 

Spoiler

Pleasantly surprised. As soon as I heard Tattooine I was harrumphing - why can't Star Wars do anything NEW back to Mos Eisley meh. But hey they went to a different "Mos" yay! Then you see the mando armour and think oh for fuck's sake they brought HIM back - then bait and switch which was nice

 

In the end the Tattooine element did not bother me so much, maybe because the story this time was much better... still filler level A team but better maybe an episode for sweeps week :D. This episode almost mirrors the village episode in season one and it is hard to pinpoint why this one works much better.The performance from Mando was better and he wasn't overshadowed by the other characters so he is rising to meet the challenge as it were. Timothy Olyphant helped as I love him as a character actor and he was not chewing scenery, which he has a habit of doing! Great performances and a good story of the week and not too many memberberries.

 

 

 

 

YES I saw the reveal at the end - a problem/annoyance for another day :D

3/5

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Pob changed the title to The Mandalorian - Season 2 (open spoilers for big surprises)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue. Use of this website is subject to our Privacy Policy, Terms of Use, and Guidelines.