The Big Star Trek Series ranking thread - vote for your favourites!

[Mogster]

29 minutes ago, monkeydog said:

 

I just didn't find much of that exciting at the time.  A three minute edit doesn't help.

I watched The Way of the Warrior again recently, and it's still absolutely brilliant. I genuinely don't know how you could describe it as "boring".

 

It was also followed by The Visitor, which is a shift to a really thoughtful, emotional episode. Together they show just how much of a range DS9 offered, and how well it handled everything.

[Kevvy Metal]

13 hours ago, Sexton Hardcastle said:

Presumably this is a stealth way to perma-ban anyone voting for Star Trek: Burnham

 

I think Star Trek : Discovery is great! ...and if that opinion leads to a perma-ban from here for having that opinion, I'm totally down for it!

[Sexton Hardcastle]

[Hexx]

1 hour ago, Thor said:

Nice to see I'm not the only one who voted for Tucker as best engineer, he was one of the best things about Enterprise. 

 

As for side characters, there's no contest, it's DS9, hands down.

 

Quark (though I'd argue he's a main character), Rom, Brunt, Nog, Dukat, Dumar, Garak, Martok, Wayoun, Karen Wynn (sic) ... the list just goes on. I still prefer TNG overall, but only just. 

 

Armin Shimerman was main cast wasn't he?

The amazing thing about so many of DS9's side characters is how few episodes they are in, completely disproportionate to the impact/memory you have them

[monkeydog]

1 hour ago, Mogster said:

I watched The Way of the Warrior again recently, and it's still absolutely brilliant. I genuinely don't know how you could describe it as "boring".

 

It was also followed by The Visitor, which is a shift to a really thoughtful, emotional episode. Together they show just how much of a range DS9 offered, and how well it handled everything.

 

It's probably just my general sentiment towards DS9.  You have to care about the characters and stakes.  20yrs later and the only thing I really remember fondly about DS9 is Garak.

[Jammy]

For me pretty much a mix of TNG and DS9, with a couple of TOS.

 

I would have voted Defiant, but failing that it was Enterprise D from the ships there.

[Eighthours]

7 hours ago, monkeydog said:

 

I just didn't find much of that exciting at the time.  A three minute edit doesn't help.

 

It's a badly edited trailer. All those fade outs! The music not fitting! Yay!